{
  "date": "2026-10-09",
  "tool": "OpenAI built-in imagegen",
  "assetId": "archer-base-idle-v1",
  "status": "animation-draft",
  "reference": "../../art-v2/units/archer-base/concept.png",
  "prompt": "Use case: stylized-concept game animation sheet. Reference is original Ember Bastion archer-base appearance; preserve this adult female archer's chestnut bob hair and small hair tuft, brown eyes, green short cloak with round gold clasp, cream sleeves, brown leather tunic and gloves, green trousers, brown boots, wooden recurved bow held lowered in right hand, back quiver with three white-fletched arrows. Create a genuine transparent sprite sheet of EXACTLY FOUR full-body IDLE breathing frames in ONE horizontal row. Same three-quarter view facing right in all four, identical character scale, boot baseline and equipment. Frame1 neutral relaxed; frame2 subtle chest inhale and cloak lift; frame3 relaxed exhale; frame4 returns close to frame1. Feet planted at identical coordinates, no walking, no attack, no blinking eye redesign, no new weapons. Four equal cells, generous 60px transparent space around every complete figure and bow, no clipping/overlap. Chunky bright pixel contours matching reference, compact 2.5-head proportions, no smooth painted edges. Sheet 2048x768 target, actual dimensions may differ. No text, numbers, gridlines, ground, cast shadow, scene, watermark. This is an idle motion draft, not a finished directional attack sheet.",
  "additionalAssets": [
    {
      "assetId": "archer-base-attack-e-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Use case stylized-concept game sprite animation. Use referenced ORIGINAL female Ember Bastion archer as appearance reference: preserve chestnut short bob and little hair tuft, brown eyes, green cloak round gold clasp, cream sleeves, brown leather tunic/gloves, green trousers, brown boots, back quiver with white-fletched arrows, curved wooden bow. Make transparent FOUR full-body poses in ONE horizontal row, same scale and planted boot baseline, all facing RIGHT three-quarter. Basic archery attack sequence: (1) ready with bow raised toward right and one arrow nocked, (2) left arm holds wooden bow straight toward right, right hand pulls ONE bowstring and nocked arrow to cheek, full draw clearly readable, (3) release, right hand opens and moves slightly back, bowstring relaxed and NO arrow on bow (projectile separately rendered), (4) recover to lowered-bow neutral pose like reference. EXACTLY one bow, two anatomically clear hands and no spare weapons. Whole character and bow inside each equal cell with at least80px transparent margins, no clipping or overlap. No arrows flying between cells, no impact/effects/text/labels/grid/background/shadow. Bright chunky pixel art, small compact game proportions. 2048x768 target. Motion draft; keep identity across four poses, do not use four identical standing figures."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "arrow-v1",
      "status": "effect-draft",
      "prompt": "Use case stylized-concept game projectile asset. Create exactly ONE small original wooden arrow, pointing horizontally RIGHT. Short brown wooden shaft, simple cream-white three-feather fletching on left and compact gray steel triangle point on right, dark navy pixel outline and bright restrained pixel colors compatible with the original reference female archer. One whole arrow only, no bow, no hand or character, no text, no trail, glow, shadow or background. Crisp chunky pixel-art clusters, not a photorealistic arrow. Genuine transparent PNG, generous transparent space on every side. Canvas wide 1024x256 target, arrow centered. Separate projectile draft for a game preview; do not redraw the reference character."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "archer-base-attack-s-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female archer SOUTH basic attack sprite sheet. Appearance reference ONLY: chestnut short bob with tuft, brown eyes, green cloak round gold clasp, cream sleeves, leather tunic/gloves, green trousers, brown boots, wooden curved bow and back quiver. EXACT FOUR whole-character poses in one row, equal separated cells. All frames consistently face FRONT toward viewer, aim downward/south in the top-down game world. Body upright, feet fixed, not rotated image. Frame1 raise bow held across front waist, arrow aimed diagonally down toward viewer; frame2 pull string back toward cheek/chest with bow held forward DOWN; frame3 release empty bowstring, no nocked arrow, fingers open; frame4 lower bow recover. Same face/hair/clothes/head size in all four. Bow and hands clearly readable below large head. Do NOT face sideways/right. Compact bright chunky pixel outlines 2.5heads tall. Transparent 2048x768 target, generous margins, no clipping or touching adjacent cells. No flying projectile, text, labels, grid, floor, shadow, scene. Motion draft not guaranteed final."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "archer-base-attack-n-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female archer NORTH attack sheet. Use reference only for outfit, chestnut bob hair with tuft and chunky pixel style. EXACT FOUR full-body poses in one horizontal row, all seen FROM THE BACK facing AWAY/up/north in top-down game world. Rear of chestnut bob, rear green cloak and leather quiver, no visible face or eyes, no front chest buckle. Compact cream sleeves/gloves, green trousers, brown boots and wooden curved bow. All four SAME rear-facing direction, same boot baseline, identical scale and equipment. (1) back-facing ready bow lifted forward/up above shoulders, one nocked arrow pointed up; (2) pull string toward hidden cheek, bow forward/up, visible taut string; (3) release: string relaxed, pulling fingers open, no nocked arrow; (4) lower bow while staying rear-facing. Do NOT turn to front or sideways in any frame. No cloak swapping hand or quiver redesign. Transparent 2048x768 target, four isolated equal cells with ample margin around whole bow/arrow and boots. Crisp bright navy-outlined chunky pixel art, no floor/background/text/grid/shadows/effect/projectile flying between cells. Motion draft.",
      "iterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "Edit this four-pose rear-facing archer sheet. Keep rear-facing character, clothes, boot baseline, four equal horizontal cells and genuine transparency. Correct the aiming geometry in poses1 and2: BOTH nocked arrows must point VERTICALLY UP / NORTH, NEVER horizontally left or right. In pose2 remove the current sideways left-pointing arrow. Redraw ONE vertical up-pointing arrow directly aligned with a bow held horizontally across the space ABOVE/IN FRONT of the character's head as seen from rear top-down perspective. Arms hold bow forward/up, pulling hand draws the string down/back toward hidden cheek. White arrow tip at the TOP, fletching beneath toward character. Adjust bow angle and hands so release pose3 matches the same upward aiming axis, but pose3 has no nocked arrow. Pose4 stays back-facing lowered bow. All four stay NORTH/back-facing, no visible face, no text, no spare arrows between cells, no clipping. Bright chunky pixel consistency. This is a targeted directional correction.",
          "result": "Rejected: release pose still had a nocked arrow."
        },
        {
          "prompt": "Edit ONLY the THIRD panel of this FOUR-panel horizontal archer sprite sheet. In panel3 remove the entire nocked vertical arrow, including its white arrowhead at the top, its brown vertical shaft above/behind the head, and its fletching. Panel3 is AFTER RELEASE and must show EMPTY bowstring with no arrow attached. Preserve the archer's rear-facing body, brown hair, green cloak, quiver arrows (the quiver arrows stay), raised wooden bow and open release hand. Do not change panels1,2,4, the pixel style, scale, layout, boot baseline, crop margins or transparent background. No new flying arrow or effect anywhere. Do not remove arrows from the quiver. Exact targeted third-frame cleanup, transparent image.",
          "result": "Selected release cleanup; bow-shape consistency still pending."
        }
      ],
      "firstResult": "Rejected: second pose arrow pointed sideways."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-bolt-v1",
      "status": "effect-draft",
      "reference": "../../art-v2/units/frost-base/concept.png",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion frost-base basic projectile draft. Reference only the cyan crystalline staff palette and crisp chunky pixel outlines. Exactly ONE small horizontal RIGHT-pointing ice shard, cyan/deep blue faceted crystal core with a white tip and two tiny ice-chip accents at the left tail. Compact simple readable silhouette for 16-32px game display. No caster, staff, bow, weapon, text, grid, scene, snow background, glow cloud, shadow or impact explosion. Genuine transparent PNG and broad clear transparent margins, one isolated projectile. Bright cheerful navy-outlined pixel clusters compatible with the project reference. Static projectile appearance, not an animation sheet or new spell/mechanic."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-base-idle-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "reference": "../../art-v2/units/frost-base/concept.png",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion frost-base adult female mage IDLE animation draft. Reference only for appearance: silver shoulder-length hair, blue eyes, royal blue oversized hood with cream trim, light blue coat with cream hem, blue cape, brown belt square gold buckle and boots, brown wooden staff with cyan crystal in right hand. Exactly FOUR full body breathing poses in ONE horizontal row, equal cells, all three-quarter facing right, identical scale, boot baseline, face and equipment. Frame1 relaxed, frame2 subtle inhale, frame3 exhale, frame4 return near frame1. Feet planted, staff held upright unchanged, tiny cape movement only. Chunky cheerful navy-outlined pixel art 2.5-head proportions. Genuine transparent 2048x768 target, generous empty margins around all characters/staff, no text/grid/background/floor/shadow/spell/snow/projectiles. Do not change gender, staff or costume. Four distinct but subtle poses, no walking or attacking. Motion draft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-base-attack-e-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female frost mage EAST basic casting attack sprite sheet. Reference is appearance only: silver hair, blue eyes, royal blue hood cream trim, pale blue coat and cape, belt gold square buckle, brown boots, wooden staff cyan crystal. EXACT FOUR isolated full body poses in one horizontal row equal cells. Consistently THREE QUARTER facing RIGHT/EAST, feet fixed, same scale and staff. Frame1 ready upright staff; frame2 raise crystal forward toward right, offhand draws toward chest; frame3 extend staff toward RIGHT with clear open offhand release gesture; frame4 recover upright staff. No flying projectile or effects on sheet, no newly invented spell. All four poses face east, staff crystal stays intact, no extra staff. Chunky crisp navy-outlined cheerful pixel art 2.5heads proportions. Transparent 2048x768 target with at least 35px EMPTY margins within EACH 512px cell around staff/body. No clipping, overlap, background, floor, shadows, text, grid. Motion draft, coherent weapon and face.\n",
      "iterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "Correct this four-cell frost mage EAST attack sheet: keep costume/face/4 poses/transparent background. THIRD pose staff extends into fourth cell: shrink the ENTIRE third full-body pose and its staff uniformly to fit wholly INSIDE x1024..1536 with at least30px transparent margin on both sides. Also center each other character within its own 512px cell with minimum30px margin. All FOUR characters same scale and foot baseline, so reduce all four uniformly if needed. Full staff and crystal must remain attached, third staff pointing horizontally right, no clipping, no overlap with fourth. No new props/projectiles/background/text. Four complete isolated figures. Preserve genuine transparency.\n",
          "result": "Selected with variable extraction width; initial overlapping staff rejected."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-base-attack-s-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion frost-base adult female mage SOUTH basic cast attack sheet. Use reference for silver hair/blue eyes, royal blue hood cream trim, light blue coat/cape, brown belt square gold buckle and boots, wooden cyan crystal staff. EXACT FOUR isolated full body poses in one horizontal row, equal cells, consistent FRONT VIEW facing viewer/down/south, not side-facing. Frame1 upright staff; frame2 raise staff across front chest, offhand pulls back; frame3 point crystal staff FORWARD/DOWN toward viewer below the head, open offhand releasing; frame4 recover upright staff. Same character scale, boots planted same baseline, same face/equipment. No flying projectile, no spell cloud, no grid/text/scene/floor/shadows. Transparent 2048x768 target with40px clear margin per512px cell, generous space around whole staff/body. Crisp cheerful chunky navy-outlined pixel art 2.5heads proportion. Animation draft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-base-attack-n-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion frost-base adult female mage NORTH basic casting attack sheet. Reference outfit only: royal blue hood cream trim, silver hair, light blue coat, blue cape, belt and brown boots, wooden cyan crystal staff. EXACT FOUR whole-body poses ONE horizontal row. All four seen FROM THE BACK facing AWAY/up/north, no eyes/face/front buckle visible. Same boots planted and scale. Frame1 staff upright toward front/up beside shoulder; frame2 raise staff forward above head with other hand drawing inward; frame3 extend crystal UP/NORTH in front of hood, offhand open releasing; frame4 recover upright staff, still back-facing. Rear blue hood and cape readable, staff complete/intact, no multiple staffs. Four equal isolated512px cells target2048x768, 40px transparent margins around whole figure/crystal. Crisp bright chunky navy-outlined pixelart 2.5heads proportions. Genuine transparent background, no shadows/floor/text/grid/flying projectile/spell clouds. Motion draft not game behavior.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-idle-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female lancer IDLE breathing sheet, appearance reference only. Preserve black short ponytail hair, brown eyes, silver low open helmet red ribbon, silver shoulder/chest/knee armor, red scarf and red cream tabard, brown leather belt gloves boots, long brown wooden spear with silver pointed leaf blade and red ribbon. Exactly FOUR whole-body subtle breathing poses in one horizontal row equal cells. Same three-quarter RIGHT facing, planted boots fixed baseline, spear held upright at same angle, tiny ribbon/scarf breathing only. Compact bright cheerful chunky navy-outlined pixel art 2.5head proportions. Transparent2048x768 target with40px empty margins inside each512px cell including COMPLETE spear tip and butt; no clipping/overlap. No attack/moving feet/extra weapons/shield/text/grid/scene/floor/shadows. Female face consistent. Four pose motion draft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-attack-e-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female lancer EAST basic thrust attack sprite sheet. Reference outfit: black ponytail brown eyes silver open low helmet red ribbon, silver armor, red scarf and cream-red tabard, brown boots/belt/gloves, long wooden spear silver leaf point and red ribbon. EXACT FOUR full-body poses in ONE horizontal row, all facing RIGHT/EAST, consistent boot baseline and scale. Each whole figure must be SMALL enough to fit its entire spear inside its own512px cell with35px margin, body approx240px tall if needed. Frame1 ready spear diagonally forward; frame2 pull spear back toward hip with two hands; frame3 thrust spear horizontally RIGHT at waist level both hands holding shaft, extended spear tip fully visible; frame4 recover spear toward diagonal ready. Same spear LENGTH across poses, no detached blade, no extra weapons. Keep planted boots no lunging across cells, no overlaps. Crisp bright chunky navy-outline pixelart. Genuine transparent2048x768 target, no floor/shadow/text/grid/projectile/impact/effects. Motion draft only.\n",
      "iterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "Edit this four-panel lancer attack sheet ONLY third panel: move third entire character and horizontal spear LEFT within panel3 and shorten displayed spear by foreshortening about20%, preserving attached tip/ribbon and two hands. Entire third pose must fit x1024 to1510, spear tip at x1490 or less. Do not overlap fourth character. Keep third character same scale/boot baseline and costume as other panels, whole spear intact. Preserve panels1,2,4 exactly and original transparency. No new effect/text/background. We need clearly separated sprite extraction.\n",
          "result": "Rejected: second spear tip and third ribbon still crossed cells."
        },
        {
          "prompt": "Sprite separation repair. Keep all four characters/outfits/poses. PANEL2: shorten the diagonal spear blade so its rightmost pixel is BEFORE x990, not at x1015. PANEL3: move entire body and rear helmet ribbon RIGHT 45px so every pixel is AFTER x1040; shorten horizontal spear accordingly so its point stays BEFORE x1510. Do not shrink faces. Final content bounding boxes: panel1 x25..490; panel2 x540..990; panel3 x1040..1510; panel4 x1590..2020. Clear transparent vertical gutters at x500..530 and x995..1035 and x1515..1585. No text/guides/background. Preserve boot baseline and PNG transparency. This correction is required to isolate cells without slicing ribbon or spear.\n",
          "result": "Selected actual1774x887 variable rects; spear length variation remains."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-attack-s-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female lancer SOUTH basic thrust sheet. Preserve reference black ponytail brown eyes silver open helmet red ribbon, silver chest shoulders knees armor, red scarf/tabard cream trim, brown gloves/boots/belt, brown spear silver leaf point red ribbon. Exactly FOUR isolated fullbody poses one horizontal row: FRONT facing viewer/down in all poses, planted boots same baseline. Frame1 spear upright; frame2 hold shaft across front chest draw back; frame3 thrust spear DOWN/forward toward viewer, tip below hands at center waist/thigh, clearly connected foreshortened shaft, both hands grip; frame4 recover upright. Same face/outfit/scale/weapon. Four equal512px cells with35px margin, complete weapon insideeachcell, transparent2048x768target. Bright chunky navy-outline pixel art2.5heads. No side facing, no clipping/overlap/projectile/effects/text/grid/floor/shadows. Motion draft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-attack-n-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female lancer NORTH basic thrust sheet. Reference outfit only: silver armor open low helmet red ribbon and black ponytail, red scarf cream-red tabard, brown gloves boots belt, wooden spear silver leaf blade red ribbon. EXACT FOUR fullbody poses ONE horizontal row, all seen FROM BACK facing AWAY/UP, NO face/eyes/front buckle. Same scale/boot baseline. Frame1 upright spear beside shoulder; frame2 draw spear back both hands above shoulders; frame3 thrust spear UP/NORTH above helmet, silver blade top and attached shaft between both hands; frame4 recover upright spear. Rear helmet ponytail and red scarf, silver backplate clear. Uniform 512px cells with35px EMPTY margins around COMPLETE spear. Transparent2048x768target, bright chunky navy-outline pixelart2.5heads, no floor/shadows/grid/text/projectile/effect, no facing-sideways. Motion draft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "engineer-base-idle-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Generate FOUR subtle IDLE breathing poses for this female engineer, using these holstered-hammer poses as appearance reference. Same auburn hair/brass goggles/cream coat/leather harness toolbelt olive trousers brown gloves/boots. Hammer remains HOLSTERED on belt in every idle frame, gray head and brown handle visible. Both arms lowered, exactly twohands; no guidance gestures, noheldhammer. All four same three-quarter right direction, same plantedboots baseline/scale, only subtle chest/coat breathing. Four separate equalcells512px onehorizontal row target2048x768,40pxclear transparent margins. Bright chunky navyoutlinepixelart, no text/grid/floor/shadow/effects. Preserve reference outfit and holster continuity. Motion draft.\n",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female engineer IDLE sheet appearance reference: tousled auburn brown short hair, brown eyes, brass goggles resting above forehead, cream rolled sleeve work coat, brown leather harness tool belt pouches with ruler mark, olive trousers, brown gloves/boots, small gray brass-trim hammer lowered right hand, rolled paper/tools behind hip. EXACT FOUR subtle breathing fullbody poses one horizontal row equal cells, same three-quarter RIGHT view, identical scale feet planted same baseline. Only chest/coat slight breathing, goggles/tools/hammer unchanged. Crisp bright chunky navy-outline pixelart2.5heads, transparent2048x768target,40px empty margins around all complete figures/tools. No attack/text/grid/scene/floor/shadow/effects/extra props. Motion draft.\n",
          "reason": "Valid held-hammer idle deferred to preserve chosen holstered support appearance."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "engineer-base-attack-e-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Fresh four-frame female engineer support sprite sheet, original Ember Bastion. Appearance auburn short tousled hair, brass goggles forehead, brown eyes, cream workcoat brown toolbelt/harness/pouches, olive trousers, brown boots/gloves. To avoid hand/weapon errors, hammer is HOLSTERED VERTICALLY ON LEFT TOOLBELT in EVERY frame, nobody holds hammer. Both hands empty. Exactly TWO arms and TWO hands. FOUR poses one horizontal row facing RIGHT consistently:1 both hands lowered;2 right hand raised near chest;3 same right arm extends open guiding palm toward RIGHT, left hand stays lowered;4 both hands return lowered. Hammer remains hanging at left belt visibly in every frame, same gray brass hammer head/handle. Small repeated body scale, planted boots baseline. Crisp bright chunky navy-outline pixel art, transparent2048x768target, isolated512pxcells minimum40pxclear margin fullfigures. No hammer attack, no projectile/floor/shadow/effects/text/grid. Support guidance only. Keep other toolbags consistent.\n",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female engineer EAST support gesture sheet. Reference exact auburn short tousled hair/brass forehead goggles/brown eyes/cream workcoat brown harness toolbelt bags rolledpaper olive trousers brown gloves boots/small brass-gray hammer. EXACT FOUR fullbody poses one horizontal row, all three-quarter facing RIGHT/EAST. Frame1 calm ready hammer lowered; frame2 free left hand rises toward goggles; frame3 extend free left hand palm outward pointing RIGHT to guide an allied unit, hammer remains LOWERED right hand; frame4 recover free hand. This is a range-support guidance gesture, NOT striking an enemy, no weapon swing/projectile or invented attack. Same scale plantedboot baseline same hammer and costume. Compact chunky cheerful navy-outline pixelart2.5heads, transparent2048x768,40px empty margins per512pxcell around each whole body/tool/hand. No overlap/clipping/text/grid/floor/shadow/effects/additional props. Four motion draft poses.\n",
          "reason": "Missing hammer in guiding pose."
        },
        {
          "prompt": "Fix ONLY THIRD engineer pose: restore the missing SMALL gray hammer with brass trims held in the LOWERED hand at the left hip (viewer left). Upper outstretched hand stays empty open palm guiding RIGHT. Hammer is same shape as other panels and points downward, remains within third cell, no strike. Keep body/hair/goggles/toolbags/scale/boots and all other panels unchanged. Preserve transparency and four separated poses; no new props/effects/background/text. Equipment continuity correction.\n",
          "reason": "Extra third arm/hand."
        },
        {
          "prompt": "Anatomy correction ONLY THIRD panel engineer: exactly TWO arms and TWO hands. Current third pose incorrectly has THREE arms/hands (left lowered glove, right extended guiding palm, extra right lowered hammer hand). REMOVE the extra LOWER RIGHT arm/hammer-hand entirely. Put the hammer in the EXISTING LOWER LEFT gloved hand, hanging below that hand, small gray/brass hammer head near left thigh. The RIGHT arm stays extended guiding with open palm at shoulder height. Only two arms: lower left with hammer, upper right guiding. Preserve body/hair/goggles/equipment/boots/other panels and transparency. No third arm, no floating hammer, no additional hand. Targeted anatomy repair.\n",
          "reason": "Hammer vanished from recovery/ready poses."
        },
        {
          "prompt": "Create fresh original Ember Bastion female engineer FOUR-frame EAST support animation sheet, reference appearance only. Auburn short hair brass forehead goggles brown eyes cream workcoat brown leather harness toolbelt olive pants brown gloves boots. EXACTLY TWO ARMS AND TWO HANDS per pose. One SMALL gray/brass hammer permanently held in LEFT hand at LEFT HIP, lowered, clearly visible in ALL FOUR poses. RIGHT hand is free and does gesture:1 free right hand lowered;2 right hand lifts to goggles;3 right hand extends OPEN PALM toward RIGHT/EAST;4 right hand lowered recovered. Left hammer arm NEVER moves or switches hands, never disappears; no third arm. All four face three-quarter RIGHT, same scale/boots baseline. Four isolated equalcells512px each target2048x768,40px margin allprops/extendedhand, bright chunky navy-outline pixelart. Transparent background no floor/shadows/text/grid/effects/projectiles. Range-support guidance, no strike/damage action.\n",
          "reason": "Hammer/hand continuity still invalid; regenerated holstered equipment."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "engineer-base-attack-s-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female engineer SOUTH support sheet. Appearance reference holsteredhammer engineer: auburn short hair/brass forehead goggles/brown eyes/cream coat leatherharness toolbelt+pouches olivepants brown glovesboots. SMALL gray/brass hammer stays HOLSTERED on belt, visible in ALL frames, bothhands EMPTY. EXACTLY FOUR fullbody poses ONEhorizontalrow, all FRONT VIEW facing viewer/down/south, samebootsbaseline/scale. Frame1 bothhandslowered;frame2 RIGHT hand near chest;frame3 SAME RIGHT arm extends OPEN PALM DOWN/forward toward viewer to guide ally, otherhand lowered;frame4 recover. EXACTLY TWO arms/twohands, no weapon held/swung, noextraarm/hammerfloating. Four equal512pxcells with40pxclear margins, transparent2048x768target. Bright chunky navy-outlinepixelart2.5heads, no floor/shadow/effect/projectile/text/grid. Support guidance animation draft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "engineer-base-attack-n-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female engineer NORTH support sheet using holsteredhammer reference outfit. Aubrun shorthair/brass forehead goggles strap, cream rolledsleeve coat brown leather harness toolbelt pouches rolledpaper olivepants brownboots/gloves. EXACT FOUR fullbody poses onehorizontalrow, ALL seen FROM BACK facing AWAY/UP/NORTH no face/eyes/frontbuckles visible. Exactly TWO arms/hands. Hammer holstered on belt ALLframes, never held. Frame1 botharmslowered;frame2 RIGHT forearm rises near shoulder;frame3 SAME RIGHT hand extends upward/forward open guiding palm above shoulder while leftarm stayslowered;frame4recover. Samebootbaseline/scale/gogglesstrap/toolbags. Four isolated512pxcells40pxtransparentmargin target2048x768. Bright chunky navy-outlinepixelart2.5heads, genuine transparent no floor/shadows/text/grid/effects/projectile/weaponstrike. Range support visualdraft.\n"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "banner-base-idle-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Fix FOUR-frame banner idle sheet for safe sprite extraction. Reduce EVERY navy cloth banner WIDTH to HALF current width and HEIGHT to75%, same gold wing/sword emblem and cream edge. Reduce whole figure scale about15% uniformly. Center each complete character+flag within its own512pxcell; EMPTY transparent gutters at every cellboundary at least35px. All four samebootbaseline and samepose direction, preserve female appearance navy tunic/redcape/brown boots/pole gold finial. No flag cloth/ribbon/cloak may cross a512pxcell edge or touch neighbor. Target2048x768transparent withbroadmargins no text/grid/background. Subtlefouridleposes, fullflagandpole visible. Compact width is more important than large flag.",
      "selectionNotes": "Overlapping cloth and extra-arm drafts rejected; east/north changed to 2x2 layout with measured transparent gutters.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "key": "bannerIdlePrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult FEMALE banner bearer IDLE four-frame sprite sheet. Reference appearance brown short bob brown eyes, navy tunic creamtrim, red cape goldtrim round gold brooch, brown belt/gloves/boots, gray trousers, wooden pole gold spear finial/red ribbon, navy banner creamtrim simple gold wing/sword emblem. EXACT FOUR isolated wholebody poses ONEhorizontalrow, all three-quarter facing RIGHT, plantedboots fixedbaseline/same scale. Banner pole upright in same hand, full flag and finial contained within eachcell, tiny cloth/cape breathing ripple only. Female face no beard, no costume/emblem redesign. COMPACT flag width so full pose fits512pxcell with35pxclear margin. Bright chunky navyoutlinepixelart2.5heads. Genuine transparent2048x768target. No text/grid/scene/floor/shadows/effects/weaponattack. Idlemotiondraft.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "banner-base-attack-s-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion adult female banner bearer SOUTH rally/support sheet, compact flag appearance reference. Brownbob/browneyes navycreamtrim tunic redgoldtrimcape goldbrooch brownboots/gloves/belt graypants, uprightwoodenpole goldfinial redribbon narrow navyflag creamtrim goldwing/sword emblem. EXACT FOUR fullbody poses onehorizontalrow ALL FRONT VIEW facing viewer/south.1 readyflag upright held onehand;2 lift samepolehand;3 raise flagstraightup above shoulder in SAMEHAND;4 recoverready. FREE OTHER ARM stays lowered at hip in ALL four, exactlyTWOarms/twohands, NO pointing gesture/no extra arm. Flag is compact, completecloth/finial contained in512pxcell with35pxclear margin. Samefeetbaseline/scale/emblem/gear. Bright chunky navyoutlinepixelart2.5heads, transparent2048x768target, no floor/shadows/text/grid/projectiles/effects/attack. Supportvisualonly.",
      "selectionNotes": "Overlapping cloth and extra-arm drafts rejected; east/north changed to 2x2 layout with measured transparent gutters.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportEPrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female banner bearer EAST rally/support four-frame sheet. Use compact flag reference appearance: brown bob/brown eyes navy creamtrim tunic red goldtrimcape goldbrooch brownboots/gloves/belt graypants, upright wooden flagpole goldfinial redribbon navy narrowflag creamtrim goldwing/sword emblem. EXACT FOUR isolated wholebodyposes onehorizontalrow all three-quarter facing RIGHT.1 ready uprightflag;2 draw pole hand up slightly;3 RAISE flag vertically about40px and extend freehand open guiding RIGHT;4 recover uprightready. Both hands count2; flagremainscompact upright, never a lance attack, emblem stable. Samebootsbaseline/body scale. Each fullposeincluding polefinial/cloth/extendedhand fits512pxcell with35pxclear margins. Transparent2048x768target, crisp chunky cheerful navyoutlinepixelart, no text/grid/floor/shadow/projectiles/magic effects. Supportgesture only no invented buff mechanic.",
          "reason": "Extra arm in raised pose."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportEFixPrompt",
          "prompt": "ONLY third panel anatomy correction on four-frame banner bearer sheet: REMOVE the horizontally extended guiding arm and open hand in front of chest. Third character should have exactly TWO arms: one arm raised holding the upright flagpole above shoulder, and the other arm relaxed lowered beside hip. No arm crossing front chest horizontally. Keep raised flagcloth/pole/finial, head/cape/legs/otherpanels exactly unchanged, transparent background. Support cue is just raising the flag, no pointing hand. Remove extra third arm completely. No new prop or effect.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportNPrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female banner bearer NORTH rally/support sprite sheet. Reference compact navycreamtrimflag goldwing/sword emblem, goldfinial/redribbon woodenpole; brownbob navycreamtrimtunic redgoldtrimcape brownboots/gloves/belt graypants. EXACT FOUR wholebody poses onehorizontalrow, ALL from BACK facing AWAY/UP/north no eyes/face/frontbrooch.1 flag upright at side;2 sameflaghand lifts pole;3 flag heldraisedabovehead in samehand;4readyrecovered. Other FREE ARM loweredat hip ALL frames, exactlyTWOarms/hands. Rear redcape/goldedge and brownbob readable, flagcompact fullpolecloth inside512pxcell35pxmargin. Samebootbaseline/scale/flag size. Bright chunky navyoutlinepixelart2.5heads transparent2048x768target. No weaponattack/projectile/magic/text/grid/scene/floor/shadow. Supportvisualdraft, preserve consistentemblem.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportNFixPrompt",
          "prompt": "Only THIRD panel of four rear-facing banner support poses: make navy cloth flag NARROWER by40px so its rightmost border stays BEFORE x1520; preserve gold emblem, cream edge, gold finial, redribbon, raisedpole and rear-facing character. The fourth cape begins near x1560 so a clear transparent gutter is required. Do not change other panels, character scale/boots baseline or transparency. No new text/effects/background. Third cloth must be fully separate from fourth cape.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "banner-base-attack-e-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Re-layout these EXACT four banner support poses into a TWO ROWS by TWO COLUMNS sprite sheet. TOPLEFT ready, TOPRIGHT lift, BOTTOMLEFT fully raised flag, BOTTOMRIGHT recover. Same female outfits/poses except REMOVE third-arm if any (two arms per figure). Keep each full character/pole/banner/ribbon/cape wholly inside its own large square quadrant, 100px EMPTY transparent margin on EVERY side. Smaller character size enough to create very wide gutters. Target1536x1536 square, four768x768cells. Each full figure maxheight560px/maxwidth450px. No figure touches quadrant borders or any other pose. Same relativebootsbaseline within eachrow. True transparentbackground, no guides/grid/text/floor/shadow/effects. Preserve compactflag goldemblem redcape and poseorder. Exact FOUR poses2x2not horizontal.",
      "selectionNotes": "Overlapping cloth and extra-arm drafts rejected; east/north changed to 2x2 layout with measured transparent gutters.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportEPrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female banner bearer EAST rally/support four-frame sheet. Use compact flag reference appearance: brown bob/brown eyes navy creamtrim tunic red goldtrimcape goldbrooch brownboots/gloves/belt graypants, upright wooden flagpole goldfinial redribbon navy narrowflag creamtrim goldwing/sword emblem. EXACT FOUR isolated wholebodyposes onehorizontalrow all three-quarter facing RIGHT.1 ready uprightflag;2 draw pole hand up slightly;3 RAISE flag vertically about40px and extend freehand open guiding RIGHT;4 recover uprightready. Both hands count2; flagremainscompact upright, never a lance attack, emblem stable. Samebootsbaseline/body scale. Each fullposeincluding polefinial/cloth/extendedhand fits512pxcell with35pxclear margins. Transparent2048x768target, crisp chunky cheerful navyoutlinepixelart, no text/grid/floor/shadow/projectiles/magic effects. Supportgesture only no invented buff mechanic.",
          "reason": "Extra arm in raised pose."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportEFixPrompt",
          "prompt": "ONLY third panel anatomy correction on four-frame banner bearer sheet: REMOVE the horizontally extended guiding arm and open hand in front of chest. Third character should have exactly TWO arms: one arm raised holding the upright flagpole above shoulder, and the other arm relaxed lowered beside hip. No arm crossing front chest horizontally. Keep raised flagcloth/pole/finial, head/cape/legs/otherpanels exactly unchanged, transparent background. Support cue is just raising the flag, no pointing hand. Remove extra third arm completely. No new prop or effect.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportNPrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female banner bearer NORTH rally/support sprite sheet. Reference compact navycreamtrimflag goldwing/sword emblem, goldfinial/redribbon woodenpole; brownbob navycreamtrimtunic redgoldtrimcape brownboots/gloves/belt graypants. EXACT FOUR wholebody poses onehorizontalrow, ALL from BACK facing AWAY/UP/north no eyes/face/frontbrooch.1 flag upright at side;2 sameflaghand lifts pole;3 flag heldraisedabovehead in samehand;4readyrecovered. Other FREE ARM loweredat hip ALL frames, exactlyTWOarms/hands. Rear redcape/goldedge and brownbob readable, flagcompact fullpolecloth inside512pxcell35pxmargin. Samebootbaseline/scale/flag size. Bright chunky navyoutlinepixelart2.5heads transparent2048x768target. No weaponattack/projectile/magic/text/grid/scene/floor/shadow. Supportvisualdraft, preserve consistentemblem.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportNFixPrompt",
          "prompt": "Only THIRD panel of four rear-facing banner support poses: make navy cloth flag NARROWER by40px so its rightmost border stays BEFORE x1520; preserve gold emblem, cream edge, gold finial, redribbon, raisedpole and rear-facing character. The fourth cape begins near x1560 so a clear transparent gutter is required. Do not change other panels, character scale/boots baseline or transparency. No new text/effects/background. Third cloth must be fully separate from fourth cape.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "banner-base-attack-n-v1",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Re-layout the reference's EXACT four female banner support poses into TWO ROWS by TWO COLUMNS. TOPLEFT ready, TOPRIGHT lift, BOTTOMLEFT fully raised flag, BOTTOMRIGHT recover. All face NORTH, back of head visible, no faces. Preserve brown bob, red gold-trim cape, navy tunic, brown boots, narrow navy gold-emblem banner. Exactly TWO arms per figure. Each complete pole/banner/cape/boots wholly inside its own quadrant with generous transparent gutters: character max 450px wide and 540px high within 768px square cells, target1536x1536. Especially 100px transparent gap BETWEEN ROWS and columns. Four figures only. No cropped parts, no touching borders, no text, guides, floor, shadow or background. True transparency. Flag raise is support signal only, no magic effect.",
      "selectionNotes": "Overlapping cloth and extra-arm drafts rejected; east/north changed to 2x2 layout with measured transparent gutters.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportEPrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female banner bearer EAST rally/support four-frame sheet. Use compact flag reference appearance: brown bob/brown eyes navy creamtrim tunic red goldtrimcape goldbrooch brownboots/gloves/belt graypants, upright wooden flagpole goldfinial redribbon navy narrowflag creamtrim goldwing/sword emblem. EXACT FOUR isolated wholebodyposes onehorizontalrow all three-quarter facing RIGHT.1 ready uprightflag;2 draw pole hand up slightly;3 RAISE flag vertically about40px and extend freehand open guiding RIGHT;4 recover uprightready. Both hands count2; flagremainscompact upright, never a lance attack, emblem stable. Samebootsbaseline/body scale. Each fullposeincluding polefinial/cloth/extendedhand fits512pxcell with35pxclear margins. Transparent2048x768target, crisp chunky cheerful navyoutlinepixelart, no text/grid/floor/shadow/projectiles/magic effects. Supportgesture only no invented buff mechanic.",
          "reason": "Extra arm in raised pose."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportEFixPrompt",
          "prompt": "ONLY third panel anatomy correction on four-frame banner bearer sheet: REMOVE the horizontally extended guiding arm and open hand in front of chest. Third character should have exactly TWO arms: one arm raised holding the upright flagpole above shoulder, and the other arm relaxed lowered beside hip. No arm crossing front chest horizontally. Keep raised flagcloth/pole/finial, head/cape/legs/otherpanels exactly unchanged, transparent background. Support cue is just raising the flag, no pointing hand. Remove extra third arm completely. No new prop or effect.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportNPrompt",
          "prompt": "Original Ember Bastion female banner bearer NORTH rally/support sprite sheet. Reference compact navycreamtrimflag goldwing/sword emblem, goldfinial/redribbon woodenpole; brownbob navycreamtrimtunic redgoldtrimcape brownboots/gloves/belt graypants. EXACT FOUR wholebody poses onehorizontalrow, ALL from BACK facing AWAY/UP/north no eyes/face/frontbrooch.1 flag upright at side;2 sameflaghand lifts pole;3 flag heldraisedabovehead in samehand;4readyrecovered. Other FREE ARM loweredat hip ALL frames, exactlyTWOarms/hands. Rear redcape/goldedge and brownbob readable, flagcompact fullpolecloth inside512pxcell35pxmargin. Samebootbaseline/scale/flag size. Bright chunky navyoutlinepixelart2.5heads transparent2048x768target. No weaponattack/projectile/magic/text/grid/scene/floor/shadow. Supportvisualdraft, preserve consistentemblem.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        },
        {
          "key": "bannerSupportNFixPrompt",
          "prompt": "Only THIRD panel of four rear-facing banner support poses: make navy cloth flag NARROWER by40px so its rightmost border stays BEFORE x1520; preserve gold emblem, cream edge, gold finial, redribbon, raisedpole and rear-facing character. The fourth cape begins near x1560 so a clear transparent gutter is required. Do not change other panels, character scale/boots baseline or transparency. No new text/effects/background. Third cloth must be fully separate from fourth cape.",
          "reason": "Flag/cape crossed neighboring frame boundary."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-base-idle-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference is character identity/style, not pose layout. Make a transparent FOUR FRAME idle sprite sheet, TWO ROWS TWO COLUMNS. Exact same male chibi pixel-art knight: gray closed helmet vertical visor slots, large blue plume, blue scarf/tabard, silver armor, brown boots, short silver sword gold hilt in right hand, royal blue castle-shaped shield silver border gold lantern emblem in left. Face three-quarter EAST/right in every frame. Gentle idle breath only: ready, slight inhale, settled, recover. No attack, no walking, no defensive magic. Exact FOUR complete figures, each inside a quadrant with 100px clear gutters, whole shield/plume/sword visible; consistent equipment and TWO arms. Target1536square, figures max450wide540high, no touching edges. True transparent background, no text/grid/floor/shadows/effects. Preserve coarse pixel clusters not smooth illustration."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-base-attack-e-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference identity. Create EXACT FOUR animation frames of this male pixel-art knight performing ONE sword swing toward EAST/right, laid out2x2. TL ready, TR windup sword drawn back/up, BL strike short sword extended toward right target, BR recover to ready. Feet planted, no walk, no shield bash or magic. Sword remains in RIGHT hand allfour, castle-shaped blue shield silver rim gold lantern held LEFT throughout, blue plume/scarf/gray helmet/brown boots consistent. No extra limbs. Clear distinct arm poses, two arms. Full sword/shield/plume visible INSIDE each quadrant with wide100px gutters. Target1536square, max figure450wide540high. No motion arcs/projectiles/text/floor/shadow/grid; transparent. Coarse pixel clusters with stepped edges matching source, not smooth painted outlines. Shield is appearance only."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-base-attack-s-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Create SOUTH/front-facing sword attack sprite sheet of exact male pixel knight from reference: helmet visor3verticalslots, blue plume/scarf, silver armor,brownboots; blue castle shield gold lantern in LEFT hand (viewerRIGHT), short sword goldhilt in RIGHT hand (viewerLEFT). ALLFOUR face directly toward viewer, not right. FOUR distinct poses TLready swordupright, TRwindup sword raised on viewerLEFT, BLdownward/front swordstrike toward viewer (foreshortened), BRrecover. Both equipment visible throughout, exactly2arms. No shield block/bash,walking,magic,effect. 2x2 square target1536, complete small figures max430width520height with generous transparent100px gutters and margins, no touching edges. Coarse stepped pixelclusters matching source, not smoothpainting. TRUE transparent, no shadow/floor/text/grid. Keep feet stable and sword hand consistent."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-base-attack-n-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Create NORTH/back-facing sword attack sprite sheet of reference male pixel knight. All FOUR face AWAY viewer (rear helmet solid metal, NO face/visor front), blue plume/scarf/tabard silverarmor brownboots. Sword RIGHT hand appears viewerRIGHT, blue castle shield LEFT viewerLEFT; show shield backside straps/sliver blue rim NOT duplicatedfront emblem. FOUR poses2x2: TLready, TRwindup right sword overhead, BLstrike sword extended forward/up toward northern enemy beyond figure, BRrecover. No shield/bash,defensemagic,walking. Exactly TWO arms and one sword/shield each. Whole weapon/plume/body inside quadrant generous100px gutters, target1536square, max450wide540high. Coarse pixelblocks/steppededges match reference not smooth art. Transparent no shadow/floor/text/grid/effects. Clear pose timing, stablefeet, back-facing everypose."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-idle-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference identity/style only. Transparent4frame IDLE2x2sheet, male upgraded knight Gate Guardian. EXACTreference silver closedhelmet3visorslots blueplume, thicker graygoldtrim shoulderplates, blue scarf, crenellated blue goldtrimtabard, large castle blue shield silverrim/goldlantern/goldrivets LEFT hand, heavy broad silver longsword goldhilt RIGHT hand, brownboots. Allface3quarterEAST. Gentle breathing TLready/TRinhale/BLsettle/BRrecover; sword/shieldheldsamehandsallframes, no magic/block/walk. Preserve larger/heavier equipment than base but same person. Wholefigures max450wide520high, isolated2x2quadrants100px gutters, target1536square, no touching borders. TRUEtransparency no floor/shadow/text/grid/effects. Coarse pixel clusters/steppededges matchsource."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-attack-e-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Exact male Gate Guardian knight from reference, upgraded armor goldtrim largebluecastle shield goldlantern LEFT, broadlongsilver sword RIGHT, blueplume/scarf/crenellatedtabard,brownboots. FOUR EAST/right facing CLEAVE attackframes2x2: TLready, TRheavywindup sword raisedback overhead, BLbroad horizontal right swing with planted feet, BRrecover. Shield stays LEFT visible in each, TWO arms, ONE sword. No block/bash/magic/projectile/arcs. Not a new skill: visual basicattack only. Make FIGURES SMALL enough max400wide460high in quadrants, verywide140px gutters and alloutermargins, target1536square. WHOLE longblade remains inside its own cell no overlap. Coarsepixelclusters matchsource, not smoothillustration. True transparent no floor/shadow/grid/text. Preserve consistentequipment/stance."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-attack-s-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Edit this4pose sheet: Fix TOPLEFT pose to face SOUTH directly at viewer and match other3poses. Its SWORD must be in characterRIGHT hand, viewerLEFT, pointingup. Its SHIELD must be in LEFT hand viewerRIGHT with goldlanternfront. Do NOT keep top-left east-facing mirrored equipment. ALLfour consistently swordviewerLEFT/shieldviewerRIGHT. Preserve remaining3poses outfit, blueplume goldtrimarmor shield longsword. Twoarms only. Also shrink ALLfour figures slightly within their individual2x2cells so whole sword/shield/plume have generous transparent gutters no overlap or borderclipping. No other new content, no floor/shadow/grid/text/effects. Preserve true transparency and coarsepixelstyle.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "SOUTH/front-view4frame swordcleave animation of EXACTmale GateGuardian pixelknight reference. Heavy goldrim silverpauldrons, blueplume, closedhelmet3visorslots, bluescarf crenellatedtabard,brownboots. Largebluecastle shield goldrivets/lantern stays LEFT viewerRIGHT, broadlongsword RIGHT viewerLEFT. ALLfrontfacingfourposes2x2 TLready/TRwindup swordaboveviewerLEFT/BLheavyforward downward swordstrike foreshortened/BRrecover. 2arms1sword1shield everypose. No block/bash/magic/damageeffects. Whole smallfigures fitquadrants max400width460height plus140pxtransparentgutter/margins, target1536square. Pixelclusters/steppededge source style, no smoothart. True transparent no floor/shadow/grid/text. Fullsword/plume/shield visible, feetplanted.",
          "reason": "First pose faced east and swapped sword/shield hands relative to south strike."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-attack-n-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Edit thissheet for clean extraction: SAME4north/backfacing knight poses, but SHRINK each full figure to60% of its current size and CENTER inside its OWN quadrant, preserving2x2poseorder/outfits/sword/shield. Large empty transparent margins allfourSIDES of each quadrant, at least120px; full swordtips/shields/boots never touch sheetedges, and broad CLEAR horizontal/vertical transparent corridors between quadrants. ALLFIGURES fully visible. Preserve pose drawing except scale/layout. Bottomleft lungingfoot can remain but no moving into neighbor. No new effect/background/text/grid, true transparency.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "NORTH/BACK-facing4frame basiccleave of exact male GateGuardian upgradedknight fromreference. Thickgoldtrim pauldrons grayarmor blueplume/scarf/crenellatedtabard brownboots. AllfaceAWAYviewer, rear solidhelmet NOvisor/face. Broadlongsword RIGHT viewerRIGHT; castle shield LEFT viewerLEFT show rearbrownstraps/silverrim. FOUR2x2poses TLready/TRrightarmwindup overhead/BLforwardnorth strike extendedsword up away/BRrecover. SAMEhands equipment all4, twoarms no extra. No block/bash/magic/effect. Fullfigures max400wide460high,140px transparentgutters in1536square. Coarsepixelcluster steppededges matchsource not smooth. Transparent nofloor/shadow/grid/text. Wholeplume/blade/shield fitcells and stablefeet.",
          "reason": "Blade/boots crossed row extraction boundary and recovery sword touched sheet edge; resized and relaid out."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-idle-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference identity/style only. EXACTmale upgraded duelist pixelknight: closedgrayhelmet3visor slots tallblueplume, blue scarf, blue flowingcape, blue/silverpauldrons, grayarmor/brownboots, blue waistcloth goldlanternbuckle. NOshield. LONGstraight silver greatsword goldcrossguard held with BOTH hands on ONEhandle throughout. FOURidleposes2x2 TLready/TRinhale/BLsettle/BRrecover ALL3quarterEAST. Gentlebreathing not attack/walking. Wholefigures sword/cape/plume entirelyinside quadrants verywidegutters120px; shrinkfigures max400wide460high target1536square. TRUEtransparent no background/floor/shadow/text/grid/effect. Coarsepixelclusters steppededges matchreference notsmoothillustration. Exactly2arms2hands andonesword, consistent twohandedgrip."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-attack-e-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Same EXACTfour duelist swordthrust poses/outfits2x2 order. SHRINK each complete figure to60% current size and CENTER each within its own quadrant. VERYWIDE transparent horizontal/vertical corridors between cells and120px empty margins ALLsides. Longthird swordtip and cape must stay entirely in bottomLEFT quadrant, no fourthpose cape intrusion. Preserve2hands gripping SAMEhandle in everyframe, blade/cape/plume fullyvisible noedgeclipping. NOotherchanges/noeffect/background/floor/grid/text. True transparency, same coarsepixelstyle.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "FOUR EAST/right-facing basic swordTHRUST poses of exact male Duelist pixelknight reference. TWOHANDS continuously grip SAME longsilver swordhandle below goldcrossguard, no shield, grayhelmet3visorslots tallblueplume bluescarf longbluecape silverbluearmor brownboots lanternbuckle. TLready diagonal sword, TRdrawswordback towardhip in2handgrip, BLthrust horizontal swordRIGHT at single target feet planted/torsoforward, BRrecoverdiagonal. FOUR isolated2x2poses. Exactly2arms2hands1sword. Wholeblade/cape/plume inside eachcell at least120pxclear gutters, max400wide460high target1536square. Coarsepixel steppededges. True transparency no arcs/magic/shadow/floor/grid/text. No walking, no new dashmechanic. Clear windup/strike/recovery.",
          "reason": "Long strike sword and recovery cape intruded on rectangular extraction regions; relaid out at smaller scale."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-attack-s-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Exactmale duelist pixelknight fromreference, blueplume/scarf/cape,silverbluearmor brownboots lanternbuckle NOshield, ONElongsilver sword goldcrossguard held BOTHhands on SAMEhandle. SOUTH/frontfacing fourbasicthrustposes2x2 TLready sworddiagonalviewerLEFT, TRdrawsword backatwaist2handscenter, BLthrust swordtowardviewer foreshortened point downwardfront, BRrecoverdiagonal. All4faceviewer, stablefeet torsoforwardonly. Consistent2arms2handgrip everypose. Complete smallfigures max330wide400high withinbig768cells,120pxtransparentmarginsandgutters; target1536square. Sourcecoarsepixelstyle no smoothart. No effect/dash/magic/shadow/floor/grid/text. True transparent, no croppedblade/plume/cape."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-attack-n-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Correct BOTTOMLEFT strike pose anatomy of thissheet. Duelist uses TWOHANDEDsword always: show BOTH armoredhands stacked gripping SAMEhandle BELOW goldcrossguard, both arms reachingup/forward from shoulders. Add visibly bent LEFT elbow and LEFT gauntlet grasp just below rightgauntlet; no thirdarm, no separate floatinghand. Retain BACK/NORTHview, bluecape/plume silverarmor. Keep other3poses twohandedgrip too. All4isolated2x2order. SHRINK allfigures to75% current andcenter incells so swordtip has120px emptygutters no rowoverlap. True transparent no text/effect/floor/shadows. Same pixelstyle and outfits, no shield.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "NORTH/BACK-facing4frame basicthrust of exactmale duelist pixelknight reference. Tallblueplume, silverhelmet rear SOLID noface/visor, bluecape,blue silverarmor,brownboots. NOshield. ONE longsilver greatsword goldcrossguard, BOTHhands hold SAMEhandle everypose. All4faceAWAY. TLready sworddiagonalviewerRIGHT, TRdrawsword back2hands atwaist, BLthrust swordtowardNORTHawayviewer bladeangledUP, BRrecover. Whole smallfigures max330wide400high wellCENTEREDin2x2cells with120pxtransparent margins/gutters, target1536square. 2arms2hands, not extra, swordnotfloating. Feetplanted torsoforwardonly, no dash/jump/magic/effects. Coarsepixel steppededges source style. True transparent nofloor/shadow/text/grid. Fullblade/cape/plumevisible.",
          "reason": "Rear strike appeared to use one hand; added stacked support grip and relaid out. Rear grip readability remains a final refinement item."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-final-idle-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Referenceidentitystyle. Male final GateCommander knight IDLE4poses2x2. Preserve grayclosedhelmet goldcentercrest BLUE/creamplume, fortifiedcastle bluegoldsilverpauldrons, bluescarf longcrenellatedtabard, hugebluecastle shield goldlantern silverbattlements LEFT hand, broad silverstraight sword goldcrossguard BLUE gems RIGHT hand, goldtrimarmor brownboots. All3quarterEAST. TLready/TRslightbreath/BLsettle/BRrecover; TWO arms consistent equipment, no magic/block/attack. Use small COMPLETE figures approx330wide400high inside768quadrants,120px EMPTYtransparent margins every side, widevertical/horizontalgutters, target1536square. No edgeclipping sword/shield/plume. Pixel-game renderedlike source withcrispsteppededges, no smoothphotopaint. True transparent no floor/shadow/text/grid/effect."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-final-attack-e-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Exactmale FINALGateCommander knightreference basic swordcleave4poses2x2ALL3quarterEAST: TLready, TRswordwindupup/back, BLextendbroadswordhorizontalRIGHT, BRrecover. SAME fortificationbluegoldpauldrons, grayhelmet3slots goldcrestBLUE/creamplume, bluelongtabard goldtrimarmor brownboots. Hugecastleblue shield goldlantern silverbattlements LEFT, silverbroadsword goldBLUEgemcrossguard RIGHT throughout. Twoarms oneweapon/shield. NOmagic/shieldblock/newskill/arcs. WHOLEfigures SMALL330wide400high CENTEREDindividualcells,120px transparentmargin ALLsides/gutters target1536square; longswordnevercrosses cell. Pixelgame crispsteppededges source style. True transparent no text/grid/shadow/floor. Feetplanted posesdistinct."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-final-attack-s-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "SOUTH straightFRONTview FINALGateCommander knight4basiccleaveposes2x2. ALL4faceviewer centered visor3slots, NOeast-facingready pose. ExactgoldcrestBLUE/creamplume grayhelmet, fortificationbluegoldpauldrons bluelongtabard goldarmor brownboots. SAMEequipmenthands inALL4: sword in characterRIGHT/viewerLEFT withgoldBLUEgemcrossguard, hugecastle shield inLEFT/viewerRIGHT goldlantern/silverbattlements. TLfrontready uprightbladeonviewerLEFT, TRraisebladeviewerLEFT, BLdownwardfrontstrike swordpointsdiagonallyviewerLEFTdown, BRrecoverbladeviewerLEFT. Exactly2arms shieldnevermovesacrossbody. Wholefigures max330wide400high individuallyCENTEREDin2x2target1536cells with120pxemptytransparentgutters/margins. No magic/block/skill/effect/shadow/floor/grid/text. Crispsteppedpixelgame edges source style, true transparent."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-a-final-attack-n-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Create small NORTH/BACK-facing finalGateCommander male knight4basiccleaveposes2x2. EXACTreference goldcrest blue/creamplume grayhelmet goldtrimfortificationbluepauldrons longbluecrenellatedtabard brownboots. ALL4faceAWAY, rearhelmet NOvisorface. SwordRIGHT viewerRIGHT goldBLUEgemhilt silverbroadblade, hugecastle shieldLEFT viewerLEFT rearbrownstraps/silvercastle rim. TLready/TRwindup overheadRIGHT/BLforwardnorthstrike/BRrecover. TWOarms ONEsword ONEshield consistent. VerySMALL fullfigures approx250wide320high CENTEREDinsidequadrants at least150pxemptygutters/margins, wholeblade/shield/plume visible; target1536square. Need broad completelyTRANSPARENT corridors bothrowscolumns. No magic/block/skill/effect/floor/shadow/text/grid. Crispsteppedpixelgame edges matchsource."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-final-idle-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Exactmale FINALStormSwordmaster reference identity: closedgrayhelmet3slots verytall BLUE/WHITEplume, WHITEwing-shapedlayered shoulderarmor silverplate bluescarf longBLUE/whitecape bluewaistcloth goldlanternbadge brownboots. NOshield. ONEverylongslimsilver greatsword ornategoldcurvedcrossguard gripped BOTHhands samehandle. IDLEFOURposes2x2 all3quarterEAST: ready/slightbreath/settle/recover. Keep2arms2hands consistentgear. Complete SMALLfigures approx280wide350high CENTEREDwithatleast120pxempty transparentmargins ALLsides in eachcell target1536square. Longblade/plume/cape fullyvisible nowherecrosses quadrant. Pixel-game crispsteppededges source style. True transparent no effects/magic/floor/shadow/text/grid. No attack/walking."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-final-attack-e-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Keep EXACTfour pose drawings of thisStormSwordmaster but SHRINKeach FULLfigure to55%current size, CENTER withinits OWN2x2quadrant. Allblade/cape/plume contained withinindividualcell with120px EMPTYtransparent margins EVERYside. Important bottomleft swordtip mustend before centralverticalgutter, bottomrightcape startsafter gutter. Completely empty broad corridorsbetweenrows/columns. Preserve2handgrip/whitewingpauldrons/bluewhiteplume/ornate sword andposes. No background/grid/text/effects/shadow/floor. True transparency. Noextraarm.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "ExactFINALStormSwordmaster male fromreference, silverplate WHITEwingpauldrons, tallBLUE/WHITEplume, closedhelmet bluescarf longBLUEwhitecape lanternbadge brownboots NOshield. BOTHhands hold SAME greatswordhandle underornategoldcurvedcrossguard ONEslimlongsilverblade. EAST/right basicTHRUST4poses2x2 TLready diagonal/TRdrawback2handsatwaist/BLextendgreatswordRIGHThorizontal/BRrecover. No dash/walk/magic/specialskill/arcs. Exactly2arms2hands. VERYSMALL fullfigures250wide320highCENTEREDcells, target1536square with150pxtransparentguttersALLsides, wholelongblade/cape/plume no clipping or neighboroverlap. Crispsteppedpixelgame source style, true transparent no floor/shadow/grid/text.",
          "reason": "Long strike blade/recovery cape could not be separated into rectangular cells; reduced and relaid out."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-final-attack-s-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "SOUTH straightfront4frame basicthrust of exactmale FINALStormSwordmaster reference: silverarmor WHITEwinglayerpauldrons BLUE/WHITEtallplume grayclosedhelmet3slots bluescarf longbluewhitecape lanternbadge brownboots NOshield. ONEslimlonggreatsword ornategoldcurvedcrossguard BOTHhands stacked SAMEhandle. ALL4faceviewer TLfrontready diagonalswordviewerLEFT/TRdrawbackhandscenterwaist/BLthrustforwardtowardviewer foreshortenedbladeDOWNfront/BRrecover diagonalviewerLEFT. Exactly2arms2hands1blade consistent. VERYSMALL fullfigures250wide320high CENTEREDin2x2quadrants with150pxEMPTYtransparentmarginsALLsides/gutters,target1536square. Wholeblade/cape/plumevisible. No dash/skill/magic/effect/shadow/floor/grid/text. Pixelgamecrispedges source style, true transparent."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-b-final-attack-n-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Preserve exactfour NORTHStormSwordmaster pose drawings/equipment/twohand grips, but SHRINKeach FULLfigure to65% current size and CENTERinits own2x2quadrant. Create WIDE completelyempty transparentHORIZONTAL corridor betweenupperboots andlower swordtip, andvertical corridor. Atleast120pxemptytransparentmarginsallcellsides. Thirdpose2handgripunchanged, same bluewhiteplume cape wingpauldrons goldhilt. Wholeblade/feet/capevisible no cutoffs. True transparent noeffects/shadow/floor/text/grid, samepixelgame style.",
      "rejectedIterations": [
        {
          "prompt": "NORTH/BACK view4frame basicthrust of exact male FINALStormSwordmaster. Rearsolidgrayhelmet NOface/visor, BLUEWHITEtallplume WHITEwinglayerpauldrons bluewhitecape silverarmor brownboots NOshield. ONElongslimsilverblade ornategoldcurvedcrossguard BOTHhands stackedclearlyonSAMEhandle inALLposes; show both armoredforearms reaching handle, no singlehand grip. TLready diagonalswordRIGHT/TRdrawback atwaist2hands/BLthrustnorthupaway with BOTHhands underguard visiblytogether/BRrecover. All4faceAWAY stablefeet no dash. VerySMALLfullfigures250wide320high CENTERED2x2quadrants target1536square150pxemptytransparentmargins/gutters every side, wholeblade/plume/capevisible. No magic/skill/effect/floor/shadow/grid/text. Pixelgame crispsteppededges source style, true transparent.",
          "reason": "Only2-4px alpha40 gutter between boots/blade after measurement; expanded margins to avoid outline clipping."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "knight-base-idle-style-study-v1",
      "genderProfile": "male",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Use reference ONLY as STYLE/PROPORTION/PALLETTE sample of a compact low-res game sprite, NOT as character edit or copied design. Generate ORIGINAL male 'Lantern Knight': huge round SILVER closedhelmet3verticalslits, small BLUE tuft on top, tiny shortbody blue scarf silver tunic graymittenhands tinybrownboots, blue castle-shaped LEFTshield with gold LANTERN icon, shortstraight SILVER swordgoldhilt RIGHT hand. No reference's exact heraldry/helmetshape. SIMPLE flatmutedpixelart, HUGEhead~halfbodyheight, veryshortlegs, 2-3 solidshadespermaterial, largecleanpixelclusters, no antialias/glow/gradient/painterlytextures/realistic/anime details. FOUR modest IDLE breathingposes, ALL3quarterRIGHT, 2x2sheet with largeEMPTYtransparentgutters, completefigures. Genuine TRANSPARENT background: no scenery, no backdrop, no halo, no haze, no clouds, no shadow whatsoever. Make it look like a native small pixel game unit rather than a large illustration. No text/grid/guide. Sameoutfit equipment scale eachpose.",
      "references": [
        {
          "source": "https://pixelfrog-assets.itch.io/tiny-swords",
          "role": "Private Warrior Idle reference for proportion/palette/pixel rhythm only; original PNG not published."
        }
      ],
      "earlierTrials": [
        {
          "prompt": "Create an INDEPENDENT original male castle-lantern knight IDLE sprite sheet, using FIRSTreference TinySwords ONLY for low-resolution pixel rhythm, proportions, simple shading and palette softness. SECONDreference identifies OUR custom knight's blue plume/scarf silverhelmet and bluecastle shield goldLANTERN emblem/silver sword goldhilt, not PixelFrog's unit. Do not copy first character's emblem or exact design. IMPORTANT match first's MUCHLARGER head and VERYSHORT compactbody, tiny hands/feet, oversizedhelmet about45% of totalfigureheight, reducearmor/goldornaments, NO longlegs/realistic muscle/animeillustration. TRUE lowresolution pixelart: flat limitedcolorblocks, 2shades per material, clean single-dark-pixeloutline, no gradients/antialiasing/glow/painterlytexture, no finefeathers/filigree. FOUR identical-scale idleposes TLready/TRgentlebreath/BLsettle/BRrecover, ALL3quarterRIGHT, TWOarms consistent short swordRIGHT/castleshieldLEFT. 2x2sheet withhugecleargutters, fullfigureabout90nativepixels tall depictedwith clearlyvisiblelarge squarepixelclusters. Transparent, nofloor/shadow/text/grid/labels. Need simple SMALLGAMEsprite appearance, not highdetail conceptillustration.",
          "reason": "Detailed custom concept reference retained too much ornament; low-alpha residual haze noted."
        },
        {
          "prompt": "Remove ALL blue haze/glow/halo/background and shadow from this4pose pixelknight sheet. Keep ONLY four character sprites with clean hard pixel edges: helmet/plume/armor/sword/shield/boots. Every otherpixel must be FULLYtransparent alpha0. No blueclouds, no darkmatte, no ambient shading. Preserve compactlargehead shortbody, flatpixelclusters and four2x2poses exactly; no redrawing smoother/no new details. Do not add outline halo. Genuine transparent background.",
          "reason": "Low-alpha haze persisted, not an opaque background; alpha measured0-254 and residual1-4. Replaced by simpler proportion trial."
        }
      ],
      "notes": [
        "High-resolution generated source, no native grid or final animation approval.",
        "Visual dark preview initially overstated backdrop; opacity measurement and checkerboard QA used instead."
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "archer-base-idle-style-study-v1",
      "genderProfile": "female",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Fix ONLY bow appearance in ALLFOUR sprites: a slender curved BROWNwood bow stave, one thin lightcream string connecting upper/lower tips, EMPTY FULLYTRANSPARENT opening betweenstaveandstring. Remove the large TANfilledpanel/wedge insidebow, it is NOT a wooden shield. Keep lefthand holding bowgrip samepose allfour, no arrowdraw needed. Preserve female brown bob/simpledarkeyes mutedgreencape/creamsleeves/leathertunic compactlargehead-shortbody low-respixelclusters and2x2order. Make trousers mutedolivegreen tinybrownboots to match owncharacter profile. Genuine transparent everywhere outside sprites and insidebow opening, no glow/haze/shadow/text/grid. Do not add finerhair/face details.",
      "referenceRole": "Tiny Swords private original for proportions/simple palette only, own character profile specified in text; pack PNG not published.",
      "earlierTrials": [
        {
          "prompt": "Reference ONLY for compact low-resolution pixel-game proportions/simpleflatpalette/largehead-shortbody, NOT copied character/outfit. Make ORIGINALfemale WindArcher: short warmbrown bob hair in2-3solidblocks, simpledarkpixel eyes NOanime eyelashes/largeglassyeyes, HUGEhead about45-50% totalheight, tiny shortbody/tinybrownboots, mutedGREENcape goldroundbrooch, creamshortsleeves brownleathertunic belt, simplewoodenbow inLEFT hand andsmallquiver3creamfletches onback. No reference's helmet/face/design. FOUR gentleIDLEposes TLready/TRbreath/BLsettle/BRrecover ALL3quarterRIGHT withsameequipment/silhouette/scale. Bowhandconsistent stringvisible, otherhandrelaxed, exactly2arms. 2x2sheet hugecleartransparentgutters, completefigures allparts incells. TrueLOW-RES pixelart largeflatpixelclusters 2-3shadespermaterial, no tinyhairstrands/gradients/antialias/texture. NOglow/haze/halo/shadow/floor/background/text/grid. Genuine transparent background. Aimreadable at48-64px like a native small game unit, not polishedbigillustration.",
          "reason": "Preview bow opening appeared opaque; alpha samples revealed4/255 residue rather than solid wood. Follow-up aligned olive trousers and bow; edges still pending refinement."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-base-idle-style-study-v1",
      "genderProfile": "female",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference ONLY for TinySwords compact low-res pixel proportions/simpleflatpalette, NOT copied monk character/outfit. Create ORIGINALFEMALE FrostMage: HUGE head45-50%totalheight, short SILVERhair visible inside bigmutedBLUEhood creamtrim, simpledarkpixel eyes NOanime eyelashes/largeglassyeyes, tinySHORTbody paleBLUErobe creamtrim,brownbelt,tinybrownboots, smallCYANdiamondbrooch, simplebrownstaff inLEFThand topped ONEcyan faceted diamondcrystal. No beard/no bald monk/no reference's exactdesign. FOURgentleIDLEposes2x2 TLready/TRbreath/BLsettle/BRrecover ALL3quarterRIGHT consistentstaff/hood/hair/scale, exactly2arms, otherhandrelaxed. Wholefigureincludingstafftop separatedwithhugecleartransparentgutters. True lowresolution pixelart largeflatpixelclusters 2-3shadesmaterial, nofinehairstrands/textures/gradients/antialias/glow/haze/halo/shadow/floor/background/text/grid. Genuine transparent. Readableat48-64px like compactgameunit ratherthan detailedportrait. No healing/magic effect/spellattack, idleonly.",
      "referenceRole": "Tiny Swords private original for proportions/simple palette only, own character profile specified in text; pack PNG not published."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-idle-style-study-v1",
      "genderProfile": "female",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference ONLY for TinySwords compactpixel proportions/simpleflatpalette, not copied original Lancer design. ORIGINALFEMALE spearwoman: HUGEhead45-50%bodyheight, darkponytail tiedRED ribbon, silveropenvisoredhelmet forehead allows simpledarkpixel eyes no animeface, tinySHORTarmoredbody simplegraybreastplate REDscarf/waistcloth, brownbelt tinybrownboots. LONGslenderbrown spear inLEFThand with ONEsilverteardrop spearhead andREDshort ribbon belowblade, otherhandrelaxed. Keep ownred/gray identity not reference's blueunit. FOURgentle IDLEposes2x2 TLready/TRbreath/BLsettle/BRrecover ALL3quarterRIGHT, sameequipment/hands exactly2arms. Entire spear/pony/ribbons inindividualcell withwidecleartransparentgutters. True low-resflatpixelclusters2-3shadesmaterial, nofinehair/ornament/gradient/antialias/glow/haze/halo/shadow/floor/text/grid. Genuine transparency, simplecompactunitreadable48-64px. NO attack/block/newskill; idlecomparisononly.",
      "referenceRole": "Tiny Swords private Lancer/Pawn idle for proportions/simple palette only; own character profile in text, no original PNG published."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "engineer-base-idle-style-study-v1",
      "genderProfile": "female",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference ONLY for TinySwords compactlowres proportions/simpleflatpalette, NOT copied Pawn design. ORIGINALFEMALE Engineer: HUGEhead45-50%totalheight, shortwarmBROWNbob 2-3solidblocks, largeGOLDgoggles restedONFOREHEAD above simpledarkpixele yes NOanimeface, tinySHORTbody creamrolledsleeves/apron brownleatherharness/toolbelt mutedolivepants tinybrownboots. ONEsmallGRAYsquarehammer withbrownhandle HOLSTEREDonbelt on characterLEFT side, not held, smallrolledcreamblueprint atback, simpletoolpouch. Exactly2arms bothhandsrelaxed visible; nohammerinhand/noextraarm. FOURgentleIDLEposes2x2 TLready/TRbreath/BLsettle/BRrecover ALL3quarterRIGHT consistentequipment/goggles/hair/scale, no attack/repair/newmechanic. Fullfigures insidecells widecleartransparentgutters. Genuine transparency no glow/haze/halo/shadow/floor/background/grid/text. Lowreslargeflatpixelclusters2-3shadesmaterial nofinehair/filigree/gradient/antialias, readable48-64px compactgameunit notlargeillustration.",
      "referenceRole": "Tiny Swords private Lancer/Pawn idle for proportions/simple palette only; own character profile in text, no original PNG published."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "banner-base-idle-style-study-v1",
      "genderProfile": "female",
      "status": "animation-draft",
      "prompt": "Reference ONLY for TinySwords compactlowres proportions/simpleflatpalette, NOT copied Pawn character. ORIGINALFEMALE BannerKeeper: HUGEhead45-50%bodyheight shortwarmBROWNbob simpledarkpixel eyes noanimeface, tinySHORTbody NAVYcreamtrimtunic, REDcape goldsimpleborder/brooch brownbelt graypants tinybrownboots. LEFThandholds slenderbrownPOLEgoldpointfinial REDsmallribbon and NARROWsmallNAVYflag creamtrim withsimpleGOLDwing/swordemblem, otherhandrelaxed, exactly2arms. Flagnotoversized blanket, fullpole/cloth remains inside owncell withwidegutters. FOURgentleIDLEposes2x2 TLready/TRbreath slightclothflutter/BLsettle/BRrecover all3quarterRIGHT consistentequipment/scale, no supportmagic/newbuff. Lowreslargeflatpixelclusters2-3shadesmaterial nofinehair/ornament/filigree/gradient/antialias/glow/haze/halo/shadow/floor/background/text/grid. Genuine transparency. Complete compactfigures allparts separated, readable48-64px asgameunit.",
      "referenceRole": "Tiny Swords private Lancer/Pawn idle for proportions/simple palette only; own character profile in text, no original PNG published."
    },
    {
      "assetId": "frost-base-idle-native-study-v3",
      "tool": "built-in imagegen",
      "prompt": "Use case: stylized-concept. Create a NEW small game character sprite sheet using only the supplied Tiny Swords original Monk and Warrior sprites as STYLE REFERENCES. Do not reuse those characters; create a female frost apprentice with a simple rounded blue hood, short silver fringe, cream edging, tiny blue dress body, two short brown boots, a plain wooden staff with one small cyan frost stone. Match the references' actual cute squat in-game unit drawing, muted slate outline and restrained little faces, short stubby body directly under a large head. The new character must look like a sibling unit from the same pack, NOT a large anime illustration, a polished sticker, a detailed sprite or a different pixel-art style. Four subtly distinct breathing idle poses in a spacious 2x2 sheet, neutral right/down-facing, exactly same body and equipment and feet position in each, no attacks, no effects. VERY SIMPLE visual density like a native approximately64px unit enlarged with nearest-neighbor square pixels. Flat compact color clusters, about two shades per cloth/skin/hair, very thin one logical pixel muted outline, tiny dot eyes. No heavy ink border, 3D shading, detailed folds, glows, haze, drop shadow, gradient, background, text, borders. Actual transparent background with huge blank transparent gutters. Keep the four characters compact and all staff/boots inside separate cells. Main requirement: original Tiny Swords game-unit feel, not the previous high-detail AI sprite style.",
      "referenceRole": "Private original Monk and Warrior style references only; female mage identity specified in text, no original pack pixels copied.",
      "earlierTrials": [
        {
          "prompt": "Use case: style-transfer. Asset type: transparent 2x2 four-pose sprite sheet for a cute Tiny Swords-compatible new female frost mage, a small independent addition to an existing pixel-art game. Input 1 is the edit target: own silver-haired female blue-hood frost mage. Input 2 is reference only: Pixel Frog Tiny Swords original Monk idle sheet, for squat proportions, small face, simple flat color clusters and restrained outline. Preserve the female identity, silver hair, blue hood and short blue robe with cream trim, brown boots, small wooden staff with one pale cyan crystal. Make the edit target visually belong beside the reference unit: much simpler flatter colors, thinner consistent dark outline, compact short torso and limbs, little dot eyes, no anime rendering or painted shading. Exactly four tiny-breathing idle poses in a spacious 2x2 grid; identical head/body/equipment size and same hands and staff length across all four, planted boots; only shoulder/robe motion of about one native pixel, neutral slight three-quarter right direction. Show whole staff crystal and all boots with very generous transparent gutters. Hard-edged game pixel clusters on a consistent logical grid, like a native 64-80px unit enlarged by nearest neighbor; limited roughly 16-color palette, flat two-tone shading only. Background genuinely transparent including between limbs, no haze, glow, vignette, aura, cast-shadow mist, floor, lettering, border, effect or extra props. Do not copy the original monk character. Do not add attack/skill poses. Main targeted correction: simplify outline and palette to match original game-unit art while preserving the mage's own identity.",
          "selected": false,
          "reason": "Edit retained high-detail outlining and palette:61685 opaque RGB colors and54034 alpha1to39 pixels. Shape improvement insufficient as a preferred candidate."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-idle-native-study-v1",
      "tool": "built-in imagegen",
      "prompt": "Use case: stylized-concept. Asset: a transparent four-frame IDLE sprite strip for an independent FEMALE basic lancer in Ember Bastion. The two provided Tiny Swords images are the ONLY art-style and scale masters: original Lancer_Right_Attack and Warrior_Idle. Do not reproduce their exact character; design the missing female lancer with short black hair visible under a plain gray rounded open helmet, a very small red scarf, a plain gray breastplate, tiny brown boots and a simple wooden spear with small gray tip. Keep the original game's stubby body, very short arms/legs, tiny simple face and flat muted colors. No tall anime face/body, oversized eyes, detailed hair, ornate armor, gold trim, highlights or gradients. The whole body should read like the original native sprite, not a large concept illustration. Hard square pixel clusters, crisp stepped contours, 12 flat colors maximum with no blended shades, no glow/soft edges. Composition: four equal horizontal cells, the same individual viewed slightly from above in 3/4 right, complete body and complete spear in every cell with generous transparent margins. Each frame is a tiny breathing change of the same idle stance, spear upright at her right, same helmet/hair/scarf/weapon; feet remain on one horizontal baseline. No attack, no effects, no background, no text or labels. Actual transparent background.",
      "referenceRole": [
        "Original Lancer_Right_Attack: style only",
        "Original Warrior_Idle: style only"
      ],
      "identitySource": "Existing lancer-base female roster; black hair, gray armor and red scarf retained in text"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "lancer-base-idle-native-study-v2",
      "tool": "built-in imagegen",
      "prompt": "Use case: precise-object-edit. Edit target image1: the independent female lancer four-frame idle sheet. Supporting image2 Tiny Swords Lancer_Idle is only a spear-to-body proportion reference. Change ONLY the spear length: extend the plain bare wooden shaft upward so each spear's full height is about 1.65 times that character's helmet-top-to-boot height, as in the native Lancer. The small spear tip stays the same gray size. Keep all four complete figures, identical short black hair, rounded gray helmet and armor, small red scarf, tiny boots, same right-hand grip and breathing poses, same hard flat-color pixel appearance, no extra details. Extend above the head while retaining generous transparent top margin and no clipping. Four equal horizontal cells, feet fixed on one baseline, weapons consistent between frames. Do not enlarge heads or bodies or change the view. No text, labels, effects, shadows or background. Actual transparency.",
      "target": "lancer-base/idle-native-study-v1.png",
      "referenceRole": "Original Lancer_Idle: spear/body proportion only"
    },
    {
      "assetId": "archer-base-idle-native-study-v1",
      "prompt": "Use case: stylized-concept. A transparent four-frame idle sprite strip for the existing FEMALE archer-base in Ember Bastion. Reference image1 original Tiny Swords Archer_Idle and image2 original Warrior_Idle are the ONLY style masters: tiny low-resolution sprites viewed slightly from above, muted flat color clusters, thin dark slate stepped outline, squat body and short limbs. Make an independent additional female archer, keeping chestnut short bob hair, small green shoulder cloak, cream sleeves, plain brown tunic, tiny brown boots, wooden curved bow held lowered and a small back quiver. No gold brooch/trim, no huge anime eyes, no tall body, no smooth illustration or intricate texture. Two small dark dot eyes on a plain peach face. Head about 45 percent of BODY height, short compact torso and very short legs. Four equal horizontal cells, full same character and complete bow in each, 3/4 down-right view, breathing poses only, no aiming or firing, feet on same baseline. Hand grip, quiver, bow and costume identical across frames. Use hard square pixel clusters with 12 flat colors maximum, no gradients/glow/noise/blur/soft alpha. Transparent generous margins all sides, no floor shadow, scenery, labels, letters, numbers or grid. This is an idle style-review candidate, not a new gameplay skill.",
      "tool": "built-in imagegen",
      "referenceRole": "Private original Archer_Idle/Warrior_Idle: style only; existing female identity specified in text"
    }
  ]
}
